Norway frigate collision due mainly to human factors: inquiry
A collision earlier this month between a Norwegian frigate and a Maltese oil tanker was mainly due to human factors, investigators said 29 November, ruling out a technical error at this stage.
Returning from NATO’s Trident Juncture exercises, the KNM Helge Ingstad frigate sank after crashing into the Sola TS tanker in the early hours of 8 November, in a fjord near the western Norwegian town of Bergen.
Eight of the 137 people aboard the frigate received minor injuries.
‘As we see it, this is largely due to human factors,’ Dag Liseth of Norway’s Accident Investigation Board told reporters as the preliminary findings into the cause of the accident were presented.
Investigators said the frigate’s crew appeared to have confused the tanker with land, as the lights on the tanker - which was departing an oil terminal - blended together with the terminal’s lights, and also made it impossible to see the tanker’s navigation lanterns.
Another misunderstanding also occurred. The frigate ignored the tanker’s warnings over the radio to veer starboard to avoid a collision, thinking the calls were coming from another vessel farther away in the fjord.
‘No isolated action or event caused the accident, but the accident can be explained by a series of compounded factors and circumstances,’ the accident board said in its preliminary assessment.
It also said it had no ‘indication at present that technical systems malfunctioned’.
Authorities are still trying to raise the 5,000-tonne vessel, which is almost entirely submerged.
More from Naval Warfare
-
US Navy explores 3D-printed parts for Growler, Poseidon and Arleigh Burke destroyers
USN procurement notices point to potential uses for additive manufacturing in naval aviation and shipbuilding.
-
All paths lead to autonomy: what Euronaval’s uncrewed market is telling us
At Euronaval, exhibitors argued that navies are buying uncrewed vessels now, starting with mine countermeasures and surveillance.
-
Who commands the uncrewed systems when the mothership goes down?
In October 2026, the US Navy sent an uncrewed surface vessel to sea with a carrier strike group for the first time. It is a step forward for hybrid operations, but it raises an awkward question: what happens to the drones if the ship controlling them is lost?
-
Greece’s $8.1 billion naval pipeline signals opportunities beyond frigates
Defence Insight has identified 14 upcoming Greek naval programmes, with submarine replacement, uncrewed systems and longer-term fleet renewal offering potential opportunities for suppliers.
-
Navantia pitches 64-cell F110 frigate and sets out plans for 75m autonomous vessel
With its second F110 frigate launched four months early, the Spanish shipbuilder is courting allied navies with a missile-defence upgrade and a 75m uncrewed vessel.
-
Chinese maritime militia puts naval surveillance to the test
With record deployments in the South China Sea and a newly reported sighting east of Taiwan, China’s maritime militia is putting greater pressure on regional surveillance. How can navies establish what these vessels are doing quickly and reliably enough to respond?