France fears damage after Hollande fans controversy over India arms deal

The French government said on 23 September that it feared damage to its relations with India after former President Francois Hollande stirred controversy about a major deal to sell fighter jets to New Delhi.

Hollande, who left office in May 2017, said on 21 September during a trip to India that French jet manufacturer Dassault Aviation had been given no choice about its local partner in a 2016 deal with the Indian administration.

The nationalist government of Narendra Modi agreed to buy 36 Rafale jets from Dassault, which announced afterwards it was partnering for the project with billionaire Anil Ambani rather than India’s public defence conglomerate Hindustan Aeronautics Limited.

Hollande’s announcement that Dassault ‘did not have a say in it’ added fuel to claims from India’s opposition that the New Delhi government had intervened to help Ambani, who is a supporter of Modi and hails from the same state as him.

Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne,  French Junior Minister for Foreign Affairs,  said on 23 September about Hollande: ‘I find these remarks made overseas, which concern important international relations between France and India, do not help anyone and above all do not help France.’

He said in an interview on Radio J: ‘Because one is no longer in office, causing damage to a strategic partnership between India and France by making remarks that clearly cause controversy in India is really not appropriate.’

Hollande made the comments to defend himself from accusations of a conflict of interest because Ambani’s Reliance conglomerate had partially financed a film produced by his girlfriend, Julie Gayet, in 2016.

The choice of Reliance for a highly strategic contract to upgrade India’s ageing fleet of fighter jets had caused surprise at the time because the group had no previous experience in the aeronautics industry.

Hollande’s comments were front-page news in Indian newspapers on 22 September and it was the top trending topic on Twitter.

Rahul Gandhi, head of the main opposition Congress party, who is seeking to replace Modi and his rightwing Bharatiya Janata Party in elections in 2019, went on the offensive.

He told a news conference in New Delhi: ‘An ex-president of France is calling him (the prime minister of India) a thief. It’s a question of the dignity of the office of the prime minister.’